Supreme Court To Hear Texas Abortion Case

Updated Monday, February 29, 2016 @ 8:00 PM

The Supreme Court this week will hear arguments in the Whole Women’s Health v. Hellerstedt case, which challenges the 2013 House Bill 2 Texas law threatening to close 13 of the 20 women's health care clinics that remain open in Texas. In addition to other reproductive health care services, those clinics provide abortions in the state.

This case challenges the constitutionality of two provisions of the HB2 law regulating abortion in Texas. One provision requires doctors who perform abortions to have privileges to admit patients to a local hospital; the other requires abortion clinics to have facilities that are comparable to outpatient surgical centers. Inside the courtroom, lawyers for the state of Texas' tell the judges HB2 provisions are constitutional because they are intended to protect women’s health. Outside the courtroom, state leaders like Texas Governor Greg Abbott have admitted that the law is intended to limit abortion as much as possible.

Last June, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit overturned a federal district judge's October 2013 ruling that HB2 violates the constitutional rights of women who seek an abortion as one of their reproductive health care options. The Fifth Circuit's ruling would have allowed the state to immediately enforce all provisions of HB2.

Immediately following that Fifth Circuit ruling, the Supreme Court granted plaintiff's petition asking the high court to temporarily blocked that appellate court's ruling, and Texas' enforcement of the HB2 law, pending appeal.  The plaintiffs argue the law offers little to no medical benefits to women and that the real intent of the law is to close clinics and limit women’s access to abortions.

The Fifth Circuit gave a sweeping 56 page endorsement of Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers (TRAP) law legislation anti-abortion lawmakers in Texas and other states have adopted in recent years to make abortion unavailable.

Original Post Date June 29, 2015

In a 5-4 order, the Supreme Court today temporarily blocked a ruling from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit that was set to close all but nine abortion clinics in Texas by July 1. All 20 abortion clinics open in Texas today will be able to remain open as a result of this temporary order. The Chief Justice, Justice Scalia, Justice Thomas, and Justice Alito opposed the application, according to the Supreme Court's order about the case, Whole Woman's Health, et al. v. Cole, Comm'r, TX DHS, et al.

Collin County 2016 Primary Early Voting Turnout

A total of 74,502 Dem and Rep primary ballots were cast early in Collin Co. through Friday, Feb 26th. Voter traffic on Friday was the heaviest to date with 22,334 ballots cast at early voting centers across the county. The ratio of Early to Election Day turnout will likely be about 50/50, so we will likely see about 75k total votes cast in Collin Co. Texas on Super Tuesday, for a grand total of 150,000 Dem and Rep primary ballots cast. That is well above the official turnout planning estimate of 100,000.

The 2016 cumulative early voting total of 74,502 in-person ballots cast through Friday compares to prior primary year full 11 day early voting totals of:

• 2014 R+D = 30,263
• 2012 R+D = 28,288
• 2008 R+D = 59,033 (Rep: 23,368 - Dem: 35,665)

Of the 74,502 2016 primary in-person votes cast, 16,578 (22.4%) were Democratic Party ballots, and 57,471 (77.6%) were Republican ballots.

Age Group	VAP	Reg Voters	% VAP  Reg	Total Voted	Voted Dem	% Dem	Voted Rep	% Rep
18-19	25,548	15,453	60%	1,133	464	0.62%	669	0.90%
20-24	50,490	37,243	74%	1,831	860	1.16%	971	1.31%
25-29	48,949	33,748	69%	1,646	698	0.94%	948	1.27%
30-34	65,262	37,971	58%	2,592	912	1.23%	1,680	2.26%
35-39	74,045	45,119	61%	3,468	1,073	1.44%	2,395	3.22%
40-44	80,977	54,029	67%	5,202	1,362	1.83%	3,840	5.16%
45-49	72,580	57,287	79%	6,897	1,554	2.09%	5,343	7.18%
50-54	67,865	54,993	81%	8,615	1,733	2.33%	6,882	9.25%
55-59	53,330	47,295	89%	9,050	1,853	2.49%	7,197	9.67%
60-64	40,856	36,857	90%	9,331	1,966	2.64%	7,365	9.90%
65-69	33,312	31,193	94%	9,602	1,844	2.48%	7,758	10.43%
70-74	21,918	21,392	98%	7,454	1,190	1.60%	6,264	8.42%
75-79	13,834	12,976	94%	4,344	602	0.81%	3,742	5.03%
80-84	8,743	7,694	88%	2,089	265	0.36%	1,824	2.45%
85+	8,341	6,981	84%	1,137	157	0.21%	980	1.32%
All	666,050	500,231	75%	74,391	16,533	22.22%	57,858	77.78%

Out of 500k currently registered voters, 47,907 have voted only in a prior Democratic Party primary, and 79,185 have voted in a prior Republican primary.

This year, 6,859 first time primary voters voted in the Democratic primary and 18,813 first time primary voters voted in the Republican primary.

Of the 47,907 who have voted only in a prior Democratic primary, 7,977 voted early in the 2016 primary. Of the 79,185 who have voted only in a prior Republican primary, 31,795 turned out early in 2016.

Crossover party voting was minimal with 484 prior Republican only voters voting in the Democratic primary, and 2,535 Democrats only voting in the Republican primary.

Of the 11,943 prior swing party primary voters, 4,712 voted Republican and 1,213 voted Democratic Party ballots this year.

Collin County 2016 primary turnout at early voting locations through Friday Feb 26th.

SITE	Total	Dem	% Dem	Rep	% Rep
Allen Municipal Complex EV501	7,571	1,587	21%	5,984	79%
Carpenter Park Recreation Ctr EV601	4,789	1,330	28%	3,459	72%
Maribelle M. Davis Library EV200	3,931	1,157	29%	2,774	71%
John & Judy Gay Library EV212	6,081	1,141	19%	4,940	81%
Renner-Frankford Library EV074	4,136	1,118	27%	3,018	73%
Haggard Library EV164	3,367	946	28%	2,421	72%
CC Preston Ridge Campus EV117	4,129	942	23%	3,187	77%
CC Spring Creek Campus EV050	2,282	931	41%	1,351	59%
Harrington Library EV602	3,145	903	29%	2,242	71%
PISD Admin Blvd. EV603	3,599	758	21%	2,841	79%
Rita & Truett Smith Library EV222	3,637	705	19%	2,932	81%
Collin County Elections EV504	3,771	670	18%	3,101	82%
Christ UMC EV211	3,143	655	21%	2,488	79%
Murphy Community Ctr. EV252	2,595	634	24%	1,961	76%
Parr Library EV109	3,221	615	19%	2,606	81%
CC McKinney Campus EV043	1,647	381	23%	1,266	77%
Fire Station #7 EV172	1,920	351	18%	1,569	82%
Methodist Richardson Med. EV251	1,212	335	28%	877	72%
Frisco Senior Center EV194	1,424	306	21%	1,118	79%
Collin Center Higher Edu. EV202	1,142	219	19%	923	81%
Lovejoy ISD-Spurgin Admin EV174	1,483	167	11%	1,316	89%
Texas Star Bank EV165	1,076	161	15%	915	85%
Prosper Municipal Chambers EV215	1,289	119	9%	1,170	91%
Princeton City Hall EV214	831	98	12%	733	88%
Parker City Hall EV176	670	92	14%	578	86%
Lavon City Hall EV213	621	83	13%	538	87%
Old Settlers Rec. Center EV516	341	81	24%	260	76%
Celina ISD Admin Building EV721	772	67	9%	705	91%
Lucas Community Ctr. EV041	656	56	9%	600	91%
Farmersville City Hall EV011	224	26	12%	198	88%
Total	74,049	16,578	22%	57,471	78%

Early primary turnout on Friday 2/26 for the top few EV voting centers:

SITE	Total	Dem	Dem %	Rep	Rep %
Allen Municipal Complex EV501	2,037	413	20%	1,624	80%
Carpenter Park Recreation Ctr EV601	1,413	363	26%	1,050	74%
Renner-Frankford Library EV074	1,089	299	27%	790	73%
John & Judy Gay Library EV212	1,697	276	16%	1,421	84%
Maribelle M. Davis Library EV200	1,132	272	24%	860	76%
CC Spring Creek Campus EV050	691	266	38%	425	62%
Murphy Community Ctr. EV252	922	259	28%	663	72%
PISD Admin Blvd. EV603	1,152	251	22%	901	78%
Harrington Library EV602	837	251	30%	586	70%
Haggard Library EV164	835	227	27%	608	73%
CC Preston Ridge Campus EV117	1,117	221	20%	896	80%
Rita & Truett Smith Library EV222	1,093	202	18%	891	82%
Parr Library EV109	1,069	187	17%	882	83%
Christ UMC EV211	1,091	172	16%	919	84%
Collin County Elections EV504	889	151	17%	738	83%
Fire Station #7 EV172	661	135	20%	526	80%
Frisco Senior Center EV194	559	121	22%	438	78%
Methodist Richardson Med. EV251	397	113	28%	284	72%
CC McKinney Campus EV043	522	96	18%	426	82%
Collin Center Higher Edu. EV202	378	65	17%	313	83%
Texas Star Bank EV165	366	60	16%	306	84%
Lovejoy ISD-Spurgin Admin EV174	499	56	11%	443	89%
Prosper Municipal Chambers EV215	472	38	8%	434	92%
Princeton City Hall EV214	286	31	11%	255	89%
Parker City Hall EV176	235	31	13%	204	87%
Old Settlers Rec. Center EV516	121	28	23%	93	77%
Lucas Community Ctr. EV041	323	24	7%	299	93%
Lavon City Hall EV213	206	23	11%	183	89%
Celina ISD Admin Building EV721	255	13	5%	242	95%
Total	22,021	4,620	21%	17,401	79%

Texas Early Voting Tuesday 2/16 - Friday 2/26

Registered County voters may vote early at ANY early voting location in Your County. Click here for Collin County early voting information and locations. Early Voting days and hours:

• Tuesday-Friday, February 16-19: 8am-5pm
• Saturday, February 20: 7am-7pm
• Sunday, February 21: 1-6pm
• Monday-Friday, February 22-26: 7am-7pm

Election Day is Tuesday, March 1, 7am-7pm

When voters head to the polls, they will need to bring a valid form of ID with them in order to be able to cast their vote. By Texas law, you must present one of the following:  (full details)

• Driver’s license
• Texas Election Identification Certificate(free document available through DPS)
• Personal identification card
• License to carry a handgun
• Military ID (must have a photograph)
• United States citizenship certificate (must have a photograph)
• United States passport

Except for the citizenship certificate, all of these forms of ID must be current or have expired in the last 60 days.

Early voting lasts from February 16th – 26th. All Texas voters can go to any location in their county during early voting to cast their ballot, not just their neighborhood polling location. You can find more information about early voting in your county, including hours of operation for different polling locations, through the Secretary of State’s website here. On Election Day, March 1st, in most Texas counties you must vote in your precinct -- In Some Counties Including Collin County Registered voters may vote early at ANY voting location in the County on Election day.

On our BlogTalkUSA network program "Eyes Wide Open: DemBlogTalk," my cohost Rheana Nevitt Piegols and I celebrated the first day of Texas early voting on Tuesday talking with some of the finest candidates in the state! Our distinguished guests were:

• Lon Burnam, candidate for Texas Railroad Commission;  (About the office)
• Michael Messer, candidate for Collin County Justice of the Peace precinct 3; 
• Karen Jacobs, candidate for Texas State Representative House District 33;  (Endorsed by Dallas Morning News)
• Denise Hamilton, candidate for Texas State Representative House District 89; 
• Scott Coleman, candidate for Texas State Representative House District 67; 
• District Judge Dennise Garcia, candidate for Texas Court of Appeals 5th District; and 
• Adam Bell, candidate for US House of Representatives from Texas 3rd District!  (Endorsed by Dallas Morning News)

Listen to our Eyes Wide Open: DemBlogTalk program podcast:



Also on some Collin County ballots are John Bryant for Texas State Representative District 70, and Gnanse Nelson for Texas State Representative District 66.

Not sure if you’re registered to vote in the primary? Find out here.

Voter information:

• League of Women Voters Collin County
• Dallas Morning News voters guide)

Democratic Primary Nominating Delegate Allocations

In order to win the 2016 Democratic presidential nomination, a candidate must accumulate 2,382 out of 4,761 available delegate votes to win the nominating vote at the 2016 Democratic National Convention.

There are two basic types of Democratic convention delegates: pledged and unpledged (super) delegates. A candidate is eligible to win a share of the pledged delegates at stake in a state if he or she receives at least 15 percent of votes cast in a primary or the preferences expressed in a caucus, either in a congressional district or statewide. Individuals who are pledged delegates are "pledged" to vote for the candidate to whom they are allocated at the Democratic National Convention. There are expected to be approximately 4,051 pledged delegates at the convention. There are three categories of pledged delegates: congressional district delegates, at-large delegates and pledged party leader and elected officials, or PLEO delegates.

Congressional district delegates are allocated proportionally based on the results of the primary or caucus in a congressional district. The number of district delegates that are apportioned to each congressional district is determined by the Democratic vote in each district in recent elections. At-large delegates are allocated proportionally based on the statewide results in the primary or caucus. Pledged party leaders and elected officials (PLEO delegates) are delegates by virtue of their office; PLEO delegates can include statewide elected officials, state legislators, local elected officials or party leaders. PLEO delegates are allocated proportionally based on the statewide results of the primary or caucus.

Unpledged delegates, often referred to as "super delegates," are automatic delegates to the convention and are not required to pledge their support to a presidential candidate. Unpledged delegates are members of the Democratic National Committee, Democratic members of Congress, Democratic governors, or distinguished party leaders - such as former presidents or vice presidents.  (List of Super Delegates)

There are expected to be approximately 710 unpledged Democratic convention super delegates in 2016, which makes up 15 percent of the total convention delegate number. If an unpledged delegate is unable to attend the convention, an alternate delegate is not substituted as a replacement.

An Associated Press survey conducted in November found 357 super delegates "planned" to support Hillary Clinton, 14 planned to support Bernie Sanders, and 339 remain publicly uncommitted and available to either candidate.

While super delegates are free to back whomever they choose at the convention, to count 357 super delegates as sure votes for Clinton at this stage is putting the cart before the horse. It’s highly unlikely they will come into play in the first place. If Sanders were to arrive at the convention with a majority of bound delegates, but fewer than the 2,382 needed to secure the nomination, it’s hard to imagine the super delegates would dare to buck the will of Democratic primary voters by swinging the count to Clinton’s favor.

For more perspective on super delegates, click this link: WaPo: Will superdelegates pick the Democratic nominee? Here’s everything you need to know.

Democratic Primary Nominating Delegate Allocation Table - Updated 2/11/15 @ 9:25 am cst

Limited Ballots For Texas Early Primary Voting

Texas Election Law requires voters to vote in the county in which they currently reside. During the early voting period, and only during early voting, voters who find they are not registered in the county in which they currently reside when the go to vote, but find they remain registered to vote in a former Texas county of residence, may vote a "limited ballot" in the county in which they currently reside.  It is a violation of Texas Election Law for voters who have moved to a new county to return to their former county to voter, even though they remain registered in their former county of residence.

I have repeated that first paragraph of words many dozens of times during early voting of each election like the primary election starting on Tuesday, February 16th, for most of this century.

One of most common voter problem I and other Texas Election Judges encounter during every election is the failure of Texas Department of Public Safety (DPS) offices to register some people to vote when they obtained, updated or renewed their driver's license. Over a third of all new Texas voter registrations original with Texas DPS.

The National Voter Registration Act of 1993 - the "Motor Voter Act" as it's commonly known - was signed into federal law by President Bill Clinton on May 20, 1993, taking effect on January 1, 1995.

The Motor Voter law expanded voting rights by requiring state governments to offer everyone eligible to vote the opportunity to complete a voter registration application when they obtain, update or renew their driver's license, or other form of identification card issued by the DPS. The federal law indicates the voter registration shall be made or updated, but Texas DPS implemented the law in a way that effectively requires voters to affirmatively request the voter registration action.